
Over the past two years of reading fantasy and critiquing it, I have come to notice many flaws and cliches that surround the genre like a perpetual fog. Through the fog, I feel that I have identified in my own mind what makes a good or bad fantasy novel. It seems that many writers whose work I have read or heard of make at least two of the three following mistakes.
1. They attempt to accomplish overly much, and to give an account of a multitude of characters. I believe that a story can be complex and intricate, but the writer should limit himself to encompassing only two or three major characters.
2. The writers tend to focus on the character's journey of self-enpowerment far, far too much. Never- the- less this aspect can at times, be compelling if portrayed in the proper light, and with the proper focus.
3. Fantasies often become distracted and fall into the trap of becoming formulaic. A fantasy writer should decide on what point he wishes to most strongly emphasize. This he should decide before he even touches his pen to the empty page!
On the flip side of all this criticism, there are certain qualities of writing which I believe can, if used properly, be the makings of an extremely compelling and enthralling epic.
1. The characters must be admirable, but not perfect, comparable to the mundane, but by no means unextraordinary. Formidable, but not overly so. Often it is the mistake of the writer to make the character powerful and perfect. However, it is even worse if the character is weak and self-serving! In order to create a hero that everyone can root for, the writer must locate a balance between the aforementioned qualities.
2. Some may disagree with me on this point, but in order to make a fantasy inspiring to its audience, there must be a definite good and evil, for there is no point in risking one's life for his friends, his country, his family, or even himself if there is no right or wrong.
3. The story, the characters, the locations and the creatures of his fantastic world, must be well-described, but not overly detailed. For if the writer falls into the pit of boring his readers with lengthy description, and/or overly complicated conversation, he will soon lose his audience!
Since I am very interested in this subject and am just beginning to create a fantasy novel of my own, I would greatly appreciate anyone who has any experience or ideas on the subject to respond to this blog. I do not claim to be a critic and a connoisseur of the world's fantasy novels. I simply thought it might be fun to state my opinions/ ideas on the subject of fantasy and to open up a possible thread for discussion.
by Sir Colin